De ADAS of gevorderde rij-assistent van Tesla stak er (ver) bovenuit bij ADAS-testen in China. 36 wagens werden er in de praktijk getest.
Ook systemen met Lidar kon Tesla ver achter zich laten.
Ook bij de testen in de stad was Tesla op 1 met het model X (8 op 9), het model 3 haalde daar maar middelmatige 5 op 9.
Citaat:
https://carnewschina.com/2025/07/24/...s-216-crashes/
China’s massive ADAS test: 36 cars, 15 hazard scenarios, 216 crashes
4 min to read, Jul 24, 2025
Chinese media outlet Dongchedi conducted a large ADAS test of 36 cars in 15 obstacle scenarios. Six of them were travelling at high speeds on the expressway, and nine of them were in urban scenarios.
Let’s look at the ranking of the highway advanced driver-assistance system (ADAS) tests. A total of 36 cars were tested in six different scenarios, ranging from a sudden highway stop to avoiding a construction site and a collision with a wild pig. Yes (Y) means that the car passed the test by successfully changing the line or by activating autonomous emergency braking (AEB). No (N) means the car crashed.
Highway driving ADAS test ranking
The Tesla Model 3 sedan and Model X SUV took the first and second positions, respectively, receiving 5/6 points and passing nearly all the test scenarios. The Model X was also the only car that successfully avoided the encounter with the wild pig. Unlike most of the other cars, Tesla vehicles were not equipped with lidar. The third spot went surprisingly to Great Wall Motor’s Wey Lanshan (also known as Wey 07) with its Coffee Pilot Ultra ADAS.
The last positions went to cars such as Zeekr 7X, Xpeng P7+, Onvo L60, Firefly EV, or Mercedes-Benz C-Class, which didn’t avoid any of the scenarios.
Interestingly, cars from the same brands, equipped with the same ADAS, sometimes solved different situations differently. This can be caused by a slightly different software version, different sensor positions that send inputs to the ADAS software, or different ADAS chips with varying computing power, which can influence reaction time or other variables occurring in real-life testing.
Urban driving ADAS test ranking
26 cars were tested in nine different urban driving scenarios, including entering a roundabout, making a U-turn, encountering pedestrians crossing, or interacting with an aggressive e-bike.
Tesla got the first spot again with Model X, passing 8 out of 9 scenarios successfully. It was followed by Luxeed R7, equipped with Huawei’s ADS, and Avatr 12, also equipped with Huawei’s ADS ADAS.
Zeekr 7X and Onvo L60 were again among the losers, joined by Baojun Xiangjing and Wey Lanshan, which performed well in highway scenarios.
Here is the video from the testing:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xumyEf-WRI
|
ook:
https://x.com/SawyerMerritt/status/1948055082467004544
NEWS: Chinese media tested ADAS in various scenarios, including highways & night driving.
@Tesla's vision-based system outperformed emerging Chinese brands like Huawei & Xiaomi, as well as traditional automakers. Even with LiDAR, competitors’ ADAS performance lags behind Tesla.
Rankings
Top Performers:
•
Tesla Model 3 (RWD Refreshed) – 5/6
• Tesla Model X (2023 LR Refreshed) – 5/6
• Xpeng G6 – 3/6
• Wenjie M9 – 3/6
• Zhijle R7 – 3/6
• BYD Z9GT EV – 3/6
Mid-Tier:
• Aion RT (2025) – 2/6
• Platinum 3X – 2/6
• Avita 12 – 2/6
• Wenjie M7 – 2/5
• Avita 07 – 2/5
Low Performers:
• Ideal L6 – 1/6
• Xiaomi SU7 – 1/5
• Wenjie M8 – 1/5
• QinLDM – 1/5
• iCAR V23 – 1/5
• Xiaomi SU7 Ultra (2025) – 1/4
• BYD Seagull – 1/4
• NIO ES6 – 1/4
Failed All Tests (0 Passes):
• Zeekr 001 (2025 YOU Edition) – 0/6
• Baojun Enjoy PHEV – 0/6
• Lynk & Co – 0/6
• Han LEV – 0/5
• Zero runing C10 – 0/5
• PASSAT – 0/5
• GAC Honda P7 – 0/5
• Zeekr 7X (2025 100kWh) – 0/5
• Xpeng P7+ – 0/4
• Song Pro DM – 0/4
• Letao L60 – 0/4
• Star Era ET – 0/4
• Firefly – 0/4
Highway scenario ADAS tests. Y/N means pass rate: Car’s ADAS avoided collision either by automatically changing lane or by emergency braking. Credit: Dongchedi, compiled by CarNewsChina
Model/Scenario Score Enering round-about Merging within round-about Children crossing Broken-down car avoidance Standard U-turn Diagonall pedestrian intrusion Reverse challenge Aggressive e-bike Blind spot, left turn
Tesla Model X 8/9 Y Y Y Y Y Y N Y Y
Luxeed R7 7/9 N Y Y Y N Y Y Y Y
Avatr 12 7/9 Y Y Y N N Y Y Y Y
Toyota bZ3X 7/9 Y Y Y Y Y N N Y Y
Avatr 07 6/9 N Y Y Y N Y Y Y N
BYD’s FCB Bao 5 6/9 N Y Y Y N Y Y Y N
Aito M7 5/9 N Y Y Y N Y Y N N
Aito M8 5/9 N Y Y N N Y Y Y N
Tesla Model 3 5/9 Y N Y N N Y N Y Y
Aito M9 5/9 N Y Y N N Y Y Y N
denza Z9 GT EV 5/9 N Y Y N Y N Y N Y
Aion RT 5/9 N Y Y Y Y Y N N N
Lynk & Co 900 4/9 Y N N Y Y Y N N N
BYD Han L EV 4/9 N Y N Y N N Y Y N
Nio ES6 4/9 Y Y Y N N N N N Y
Xpeng G6 3/9 N Y N Y Y N N N N
Xpeng P7+ 3/9 N Y N Y Y N N N N
Xiaomi SU7 3/9 N Y N N Y N N N Y
Xiaomi SU7 Ultra 3/9 N Y N N N Y N N Y
BYD Han DM 3/9 N Y Y N Y N N N N
Li Auto L6 3/9 N Y Y N Y N N N N
GWM Wey Lanshan 2/9 N Y N N N Y N N N
Zeekr 7X 2/8 N N N – N Y N N Y
Zeekr 001 1/9 N N N N N Y N N N
Onvo L60 1/9 N N N Y N N N N N
Baojun Xiangjing 0/9 N N N N N N N N N
Urban scenario ADAS tests. Credit: Dongchedi, compiled by CarNewsChina
Full 1.5 hour video in thread below: