[TV-verslaafde]

Oorspronkelijk geplaatst door Dadeemelee

Schitterend, een belediging en een Godwin als argumenten.

Ja, maar je antwoord niet op de vraag. Is de islam autoritair?

COHERENCE OF AUTHORITY AND DOCTRINE
There is a correlative relation and cohesion between the authority and the doctrine. The authority infers the rulings from the doctrine. No doctrine exists without an authority, and no authority exists without a doctrine. The essential chore of the authority is demonstrating the divine belief. The prophet, followed by the authority, substantiates the very intendment of Allah, the Exalted. The divine doctrine determined the boundaries of the words, deeds, goals and means of attaining these goals. Also, the divine doctrine constituted the relationship between the believers and their doctrine in all levels. Thus, the role of the authority is restricted in elucidating the doctrine thoroughly and typifying it with the novel eventualities.
The authority is the only responsible of transferring the texts, rulings and purposes of the doctrine from hypothesis into application. In other words, the authority is the one in charge of applying words on levels of solicitation and administration. In this regard, the Prophet's presentation of the divine doctrine is a part of that doctrine and reckoned with the numerous contents of it. While the presentation of Ali, Al-Hassan, Al-Hussein, Zeinul-Abidin, Ja'far As-Sadiq or any other imam is seen as one of the constitutional precedents that are necessary for those who propose to make their deeds coincide with the divine intendment. Hence, the presentation of the authorities succeeding the Prophet (peace be upon him and his family) is not reckoned as a part of the doctrine. However, such a presentation is obligatory upon the individual believing in the legitimacy of that individual's authority. Doctrinally, it is illicit to contravene the legitimate imam who represents the Prophet (peace be upon him and his family). Thus, compliance to this authority is accounted as same as compliance to the Prophet (peace be upon him and his family).

http://www.imamreza.net/eng/imamreza.php?id=3359

De profeet (Mohammed) wordt gezien als de ultieme autoriteit in de islam. Dus alles wat een moslim zegt is een drogreden namelijk; argument met beroep op autoriteit.