Citaat:
Oorspronkelijk geplaatst door patrickve
En, zoals ik al stelde, vele technische details in de serie zijn juist, maar de mee te dragen boodschap steunt op een verkeerde voorstelling van de historische feiten.
Het belangrijkste zijnde dat Legasov niet eens aanwezig was op dat proces, en dat hij nooit aan de kant werd gezet door de KGB.
Haal die twee dingen weg uit de serie, en ze verliest het gros van haar "leugen" beschuldiging.
|
Hier is een nog betere samenvatting van wat er "politiek" met Legasov aan was:
https://www.nightcourt.ca/home/2019/...ernobyl-finale
Citaat:
|
he opening scene with Legasov and the KGB director as well as the trial itself is where we deviate significantly from reality, Legasov kept up his public ‘cover story’ until some time after the trial was over, and although testimony was given at the trial about the design flaws, it was not from Legasov. Although the episode paints Legasov’s colleagues as the ones who would argue for reform in a unified voice, in actuality physicists repeated the state’s narrative about blaming the operators wholly for the disaster and not the reactors they had designed.
|
DIT is het belangrijke: Legasov was eigenlijk de baas van de reactor designers: het was vice president van het Kurchatov instituut dat de goedkeuring voor de reactor had gegeven.
Dit hier is ook interessant:
Citaat:
|
Legasov then became more extreme in his reforms, arguing for changes that would challenge the hegemony of the state, and for the breakup of the Ministry of Machine Medium Building. The reaction to this was even more pronounced, not only did the old guard resent him, but even his colleagues amenable to reforms saw his rise to power and prestige as a function of the very communist state he was now arguing against.
|
En deze is ook goed om te bekijken:
Citaat:
|
In reality it was the director of the Kurchatov institute that had promised this to him, but he never received it due to Gorbachev deciding that no one from the institute should be rewarded for a disaster he perceived them as helping to create.
|