Ayaan Hirsi Ali over Boko haram

[Karel Martel B]

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/...49603782621352

Organizations like Boko Haram do not arise in isolation. The men who establish Islamist groups, whether in Africa (Nigeria, Somalia, Mali), Southwest Asia (Afghanistan, Pakistan), or even Europe (U.K., Spain and the Netherlands), are members of long-established Muslim communities, most of whose members are happy to lead peaceful lives. To understand why the jihadists are flourishing, you need to understand the dynamics within those communities.

So, imagine an angry young man in any Muslim community anywhere in the world. Imagine him trying to establish an association of men dedicated to the practice of the Sunnah (the tradition of guidance from the Prophet Muhammad ). Much of the young man's preaching will address the place of women. He will recommend that girls and women be kept indoors and covered from head to toe if they are to venture outside. He will also condemn the permissiveness of Western society.

What kind of response will he meet? In the U.S. and in Europe, some moderate Muslims might quietly draw him to the attention of authorities. Women might voice concerns about the attacks on their freedoms. But in other parts of the world, where law and order are lacking, such young men and their extremist messages thrive.

Where governments are weak, corrupt or nonexistent, the message of Boko Haram and its counterparts is especially compelling. Not implausibly, they can blame poverty on official corruption and offer as an antidote the pure principles of the Prophet. And in these countries, women are more vulnerable and their options are fewer.

But why does our imaginary young zealot turn to violence? At first, he can count on some admiration for his fundamentalist message within the community where he starts out. He might encounter opposition from established Muslim leaders who feel threatened by him. But he perseveres because perseverance in the Sunnah is one of the most important keys to heaven. As he plods on from door to door, he gradually acquires a following. There comes a point when his following is as large as that of the Muslim community's established leaders. That's when the showdown happens—and the argument for "holy war" suddenly makes sense to him.

[Tempest]

Ayaan heeft gelijk. De kern van het probleem is het ontbreken van gezag. Nigeria is te zachtaardig tegenover de Islamieten - en kijk, hoe aardiger de staat opstelt, hoe wreder de barbaren toeslaan.

Kijk naar Egypte voor het tegenovergestelde: de militaire elite heeft met harde hand vrede en stabiliteit gebracht. Want met de Moslim Broederschap valt echt niet te onderhandelen. Toegevingen doen is fundamenteel futiel. Alleen keihard toeslaan werkt. Anders is het wachten tot alle Egyptische vrouwen verkracht worden en alle piramides gedynamieteerd door "democratisch gekozen" terroristen
.